The successful merger between Disney and Pixar was not without turbulence and ethical dilemmas; however, Pixar proved assertive in valuing people and authentic storytelling over capitalism. The documentary The Pixar Story (2007) delves into Pixar's timeline and early life, featuring detailed interviews with founders, investors, and CEOs. It explores the growing interest in computer animation and the resistance from artists concerned that hand-drawn animation would fade. Pixar maintained a balance, innovating while respecting classical methods and resisting standards that contradicted their values or disrespected employees.
The success of Pixar can be attributed to key individuals who shaped its culture. John Lasseter, a creative force at Pixar, started his career with Disney but left after his computer-animated film idea was rejected for not being "faster and cheaper" (00:11:35 – 00:12:30). Joined by scientist Ed Catmull, they formed Pixar with support from Steve Jobs, co-founder of Apple. Jobs' investment and the synergy between artists and engineers fueled Pixar's growth. A pivotal moment came when Disney offered Lasseter a directorial role, testing his ethics and loyalty. Lasseter's decision to stay with Pixar led to Toy Story (1995), a blockbuster hit. Despite initial disagreements with Disney over creative direction, Pixar's determination and quality production led to successes like A Bug's Life (1998) and The Incredibles (2004).
Pixar's refusal to rush sequels for profit and their support for hand-drawn animation showcased their commitment to storytelling and artistic integrity. Bob Iger's leadership at Disney aligned with Pixar's values, paving the way for a merger that preserved Pixar's culture. This unity of vision and cross-functional collaboration allowed Pixar to innovate while maintaining its ethos. Pixar's ethical decisions resonate with universal values of valuing people and originality over mere profit. Their journey reflects the transformation of Disney's management practices towards a more ethical and creative approach. Pixar and Disney have produced beloved films that stand as testaments to their shared commitment to quality entertainment.
While The Pixar Story paints a positive picture of Pixar's ethical stance and creative vision, it also sheds light on some contentious aspects of Disney's approach under previous CEOs. For instance, the documentary hints at Disney's previous focus on profit maximization at the expense of artistic integrity, as evidenced by their initial skepticism towards Pixar's innovative techniques and their push for commercially viable but creatively compromised directions in some projects. Under the leadership of former CEOs like Michael Eisner, Disney's management style was criticized for being toxic and narrowly focused on financial gains. This approach sometimes led to clashes with creative partners like Pixar, where conflicting priorities emerged between artistic innovation and immediate profits.
Additionally, Disney's historical reliance on sequels and spin-offs, driven by commercial motives rather than artistic merit, has been a point of contention within the industry. This strategy, while profitable, has often been criticized for diluting the originality and magic of beloved franchises. However, it's worth noting that Disney's management practices have evolved under current CEO Bob Iger and subsequently under his successors (though not as quickly as they should). The alignment of values between Pixar and Disney post-merger, as highlighted in The Pixar Story, reflects a positive shift towards prioritizing creativity and ethical business practices. Let's hope it stays that way.
So, the question is, did Pixar save Disney?
References
Â
Cardenas, J., Paynter, R., Sarra, J., Bdzil, T., & Nadal, K. B. (Eds.). (2022). Business and film: A
reader. Zovio
Haley, J. M., & Sidky, M. H. (2006, January 26). How ethical leadership made Disney Pixar into a ... yumpu.com. Retrieved February 14, 2022, from https://www.yumpu.com/en/document/view/7927805/how-ethical-leadership-made-disney-pixar-into-a-
IMDb.com. (1998, November 25). A Bug's Life. IMDb. Retrieved February 14, 2022, from https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0120623/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1
IMDb.com. (2004, November 5). The Incredibles. IMDb. Retrieved February 14, 2022, from https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0317705/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1Â
IMDb.com. (2007, August 28). The Pixar story. IMDb. Retrieved February 14, 2022, from https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1059955/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1
IMDb.com. (1995, November 22). Toy story. IMDb. Retrieved February 14, 2022, from https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0114709/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1